Kao nije namesteno, hehhe :)) a-squared ima mnogo false positives, znam iz iskustva, a ovde je svrstan kao EXPERT...evo drugog testa koji to rusi...ovo je smao u vezi sa A2 antimalware...on je Super Antivirus i malwarebytes stavio na dno a zapravo su u vrhu...i po mom misljenju koje se slaze sa:
100% znam da nije namesteno jer znam decka koji je osnivac te grupe a za malwarebytes je rekao u sedmom postu u toj temi: `Just a quick note, Malwarebytes Anti-Malware didn`t perform good because we used a huge malware sample, but Malwarebytes Anti-Mlaware is more the useful when it comes to detecting and REMOVING types of malware which are ether undetected or can`t be removed by other programs, so it is not bad as it looks`
Ta tema je prilicno slozena, jadan AV produkt ce neku teku onzaciti kao virus (+) a drugi pak nece (-)...ko je u pravu? To zahteva dublju analizu. Pitanje je koji procenat podmetnutih fajlova zapravo i jeste maliciozan a koliko njih u stvari nije...treba se osloniti na srednju sumu sudova, uzmes sve ocene od razlicitih `experata` zajedno pa nadjes zlatnu sredinu. Iz iskustva znam koliko je Emsi A2 zapravo inferioran u odnosu na KIS ili ESS pa se ne moze smatrati kvalitetnim, kako su oni napisali. Emsi A2 je znacajno losiji u detekciji i u false positives od SUPERAntiSpyware, Malwarebytes i SpyBot S&D.
P.S. ovlas gledano ono sto su oni uradili nije nista novo niti spektakularno, a koliko je pristrasno ili subjektivno u to ne ulazim. Sto se mene tice ti rezultati su obicna nebuloza, bez ikakvog profesionalnog znacaja i slobodno cu reci da nemaju neke veze sa mozgom! Evo pogledajte samo nebulozni spisak, onaj poslednji pogotovo, ljudi su skroz imzesali stvari a kako su dosli do zakljucaka, pitacemo Milana Tarota :))
The Results (Name/Detection Rate)
1. a-squared Anti-Malware - 99.12% 2. AntiVir PE Premium - 98.88% 3. Avast! - 98.75% 4. Norton Antivirus - 98.69% 5. Ikarus Virus Utilities - 98.48% 6. Kaspersky Antivirus - 97.83% 7. BitDefender Antivirus-97.79% 8. F-Secure -97.21% 9. Zone Alarm-96.91% 10. Spy Emergency-95.64% 11. McAfee VirusScan Plus - 94.18% 12. Comodo Internet Security - 92.53% 13. Twister Anti-TrojanVirus - 92.49% 14. Rising Antivirus - 92.27% 15. Dr.Web- 92.04% 16. Norman Antivirus & Antispyware - 91.78% 17. Blink Personal Edition - 90.93% 18. PC Tools Internet Security - 89.77% 19. Nod32- 88.35% 20. AVG Antivirus - 87.45% 21. Microsoft Windows Live OneCare - 87.12% 22. MoonSecure Antivirus - 86.43% 23. Spy Sweeper with Antivirus - 84.64% 24. TrendMicro Internet Security- 84.13% 25. Spyware Terminator with Antivirus- 61.38% 26. VIPRE- 60.97% 27. 123 Spyware Free - 57.68% 28. Ad Aware - 28.04% 29. SuperAntiSpyware - 07.24% 30. Malwarebytes Anti-Malware - 02.66%
Speed and VB100 Award
1. a-squared Anti-Malware - average - N/A 2. AntiVir PE Premium - fast - Passed 3. Avast! - average - Passed 4. Norton Antivirus - average - Passed 5. Ikarus Virus Utilities - average - Failed(37 wildlist misses, 8 false positives) 6. Kaspersky Antivirus - average - Passed 7. BitDefender Antivirus - average - Failed(4 false positives) 8. F-Secure - average - Passed 9. Zone Alarm - average - N/A 10. Spy Emergency - very slow - N/A 11. McAfee VirusScan Plus - slow - Passed 12. Comodo Internet Security - fast - NA 13. Twister Anti-TrojanVirus - average - N/A 14. Rising Antivirus - average - Passed 15. Dr.Web - average - N/A 16. Norman Antivirus & Antispyware - slow - Passed 17. Blink Personal Edition - average - N/A 18. PC Tools Internet Security - average - Passed 19. Nod32 - fast - Passed 20. AVG Antivirus - average - Passed 21. Microsoft Windows Live OneCare - average - N/A 22. MoonSecure Antivirus - very slow - N/A 23. Spy Sweeper with Antivirus - slow - Passed 24. TrendMicro Internet Security - average - Failed(3 wildlist misses, 2 false positives) 25. Spyware Terminator with Antivirus - slow - N/A 26. VIPRE - average - N/A 27. 123 Spyware Free - average - N/A 28. Ad Aware - average - N/A 29. SuperAntiSpyware - average - N/A 30. Malwarebytes Anti-Malware - average - N/A
Our Rating and User Experience Advised
1. a-squared Anti-Malware - Good - Expert 2. AntiVir PE Premium - Excellent - Average+ 3. Avast! - Excellent - Average+ 4. Norton Antivirus - Excellent - Novice 5. Ikarus Virus Utilities - Good - Expert 6. Kaspersky Antivirus - Very Good - Average 7. BitDefender Antivirus - Very Good - Average 8. F-Secure - Very Good - Novice 9. Zone Alarm - Good - Average 10. Spy Emergency - Very Good - Average 11. McAfee VirusScan Plus - Good - Novice 12. Comodo Internet Security - Good - Average 13. Twister Anti-TrojanVirus - Good - Average+ 14. Rising Antivirus - Average - Average 15. Dr.Web - Average - Average 16. Norman Antivirus & Antispyware - Average - Novice 17. Blink Personal Edition - Average - Average+ 18. PC Tools Internet Security - Average - Average 19. Nod32 - Average - Novice 20. AVG Antivirus - Average - Average 21. Microsoft Windows Live OneCare - Average - Average+ 22. MoonSecure Antivirus - Average - Average+ 23. Spy Sweeper with Antivirus - Average - Average 24. TrendMicro Internet Security - Average - Average 25. Spyware Terminator with Antivirus - Below Average - Average 26. VIPRE - Below Average - Average 27. 123 Spyware Free - Below Average - Average 28. Ad Aware - Poor - Average 29. SuperAntiSpyware - Poor - Novice 30. Malwarebytes Anti-Malware - Poor* - Novice
sam jedan sistem testirao sa nekoliko najmocnijih engine-a u najnovjim verzijama: SuperAntiSpyware 4, Malwarebytes 1.36, SpyBot SD 1.6.2, Lavasoft AdAware 2009, SpyWare Terminator+ClamWin, KAV 2009, Dr.Web 5 i NOD32 v4, ni jedan nije prijavio nikakvu posast dok je a-squared nakon toga nasao gro nekih djavola, naravno vecina su bili moji provereni fajlvi, stari nemacki Farbrauch demoi, sasvim validne aplikacije i sl...nije on los, ali jeste losiji od navedenih
Cak nisu ni postovlai ispravne podatke, npr. Dr.Web ima 25 uspeha i 25 padova na VB100, dkale ipak je neke prosao...a ne treba da stoji N/A kao da i nije ni ucestvovao u merenjima
Evo da ti pojasnim taj poslednji spisak Expert= program may have high false positive rate, interface (GUI) could be complex for users without expert computer skills. Program may display many pop up notifications that required expert skills to know what to do.
Average+= program may have false positives, interface (GUI) may be a little complex for the average user. Program may display pop up notifications that may be a little complex for the average user.
Average = program is suitable for most average users, interface (GUI) is not complex and program doesn`t display pop up notifications that an average user would find hard to understand.
Novice= program is suitable for all users, everything is easy to understand.
:: :: P.S. ovlas gledano ono sto su oni uradili nije nista novo niti spektakularno, a koliko je pristrasno ili subjektivno u to ne ulazim. Sto se mene tice ti rezultati su obicna nebuloza, bez ikakvog profesionalnog znacaja i slobodno cu reci da nemaju neke veze sa mozgom! Evo pogledajte samo nebulozni spisak, onaj poslednji pogotovo, ljudi su skroz imzesali stvari a kako su dosli do zakljucaka, pitacemo Milana Tarota :)
:: Our Rating and User Experience Advise :: :: 1. a-squared Anti-Malware - Good - Exper :: 2. AntiVir PE Premium - Excellent - Average :: 3. Avast! - Excellent - Average :: 4. Norton Antivirus - Excellent - Novic :: 5. Ikarus Virus Utilities - Good - Exper :: 6. Kaspersky Antivirus - Very Good - Averag :: 7. BitDefender Antivirus - Very Good - Averag :: 8. F-Secure - Very Good - Novic :: 9. Zone Alarm - Good - Averag :: 10. Spy Emergency - Very Good - Averag :: 11. McAfee VirusScan Plus - Good - Novic :: 12. Comodo Internet Security - Good - Averag :: 13. Twister Anti-TrojanVirus - Good - Average :: 14. Rising Antivirus - Average - Averag :: 15. Dr.Web - Average - Averag :: 16. Norman Antivirus & Antispyware - Average - Novic :: 17. Blink Personal Edition - Average - Average :: 18. PC Tools Internet Security - Average - Averag :: 19. Nod32 - Average - Novic :: 20. AVG Antivirus - Average - Averag :: 21. Microsoft Windows Live OneCare - Average - Average :: 22. MoonSecure Antivirus - Average - Average :: 23. Spy Sweeper with Antivirus - Average - Averag :: 24. TrendMicro Internet Security - Average - Averag :: 25. Spyware Terminator with Antivirus - Below Average - Averag :: 26. VIPRE - Below Average - Averag :: 27. 123 Spyware Free - Below Average - Averag :: 28. Ad Aware - Poor - Averag :: 29. SuperAntiSpyware - Poor - Novic :: 30. Malwarebytes Anti-Malware - Poor* - Novic ::
Broj postavljenih tema: 60355. Broj poslatih odgovora: 646991. Trenutno niste prijavljeni na PC Berzu i zbog toga imate status 'gosta'. Kao gost ne možete da šaljete poruke na Forum. Ako ste registrovani kao član PC Berze, prijavite se. Ako ste novi korisnik, molimo registrujte se da bi dobili mogućnost aktivnog učešća u radu Foruma.
